Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Part 5: ClearOS - Search for the Perfect Home Router

ClearOS used to be ClarkConnect. Not sure what's changed but the purpose of this post is to share some of my experiences installed ClearOS. The main issue I ran into with the install is that CD-ROM or FTP are the only supported media.

What this means is that whether you use PXE or a USB Memory stick that's really just the bootstrap part. The rest of it has to happen via FTP or CD-ROM. Since I didn't have an CD-ROM drive I chose the FTP option and the default ClearOS FTP server. It took forever. I mean I started it in the evening and checked it once in a while and it had finished sometime at night. Clearly painful. And my first install didn't even work. Second one took even longer and I gave up. So I setup an FTP Server on my workstation and shared the ClearOS ISO. Googling led me to a useful post in the ClearOS forum with the info I needed about the user id and password that was being used by the installer ("enterprise-51" / "clearos"). That did the trick and the install was much faster than before.

What ultimately led me to give up on ClearOS was performance. It was sluggish and a little bit unresponsive from the web UI and the Console. And that was with almost all features turned off (not even a DHCP server running). It was clearly overkill for what I needed and way to much for my Atom N270 with 2 GB RAM to handle.

I'm also not much of a "read the manual" kind of person. I had no trouble configuring pfSense or Endian but I really couldn't make sense of how to define my interfaces/zones with ClearOS and how to setup a captive portal, etc.

So I passed on it.... next up Endian revisitied (I got a CD-ROM drive) and a new contender: Mikrotik RouterOS.